Fake News Mafia

Business

The Gas Was The Only Line Item With A Witness

Trump Says He Is Ending Methane Restrictions. The Finance Desk Found The Gas Was The Only Line Item With A Witness

By Douglas Merritt · October 28, 2026 · 5 min read

A finance desk regulation cost ledger with rows for oil, natural gas and methane, columns for quantity, price, status and reason, with the methane row stamped witness required, beside a termination simulation showing cost zero and question blank, over a red banner reading the gas was not charged, it was asked to explain itself, and a gold band reading no witness, no column.
The gas carried no dollar charge. It carried the only reason field in the ledger.

Douglas Merritt audits a regulatory ledger after the President's methane announcement, finds no charge attached to the gas, and discovers the only cost was a column requiring someone to explain what was not in the pipe.

Filed from the Sunday spreadsheet, after the reason column was left blank

President Donald Trump said Wednesday that his administration is "terminating" a Biden-era rule aimed at cutting planet-warming methane emissions from oil and gas drilling. That is the event. This desk was handed the narrower question that follows a termination: what, exactly, had been priced? Douglas Merritt opened the Regulation Cost Ledger, which is not a government record and has no authority over a molecule, and found a field the gas had been carrying.

The ledger has 312 rows, four columns and one recurring disagreement about the fourth. Quantity, price, status and reason. Oil has the first three. Natural gas has the first three. Methane has the first three and, on every row in this file, a reason for a variance. The desk expected to find a charge. It found a requirement to narrate.

The Cost Was Not On The Gas

The desk has used the word restriction where the ledger says documentation. Over eight years the file records 312 methane entries. Two hundred and ninety-seven have no dollar amount in the cost column. Fifteen carry a review fee, all for a late answer, not for a molecule. The fee is the cost of making the line legible. The gas itself is not billed by this file. It is asked to bring a witness.

"The rule does not make the gas sit in a chair. It makes somebody sit in a chair and say what happened to the gas. If the answer is we do not know, the ledger still has a witness. If the field is blank, the ledger has nothing."

A registrar at the Regulation Cost Ledger, by telephone, Tuesday

A Blank Is Not A Saving

The distinction matters because the desk has made it wrong before. In 38 earlier entries where a field was removed from a form, sunday.xlsx carried the missing field as zero. Zero means a quantity was measured and none was found. Blank means the question was not asked. The two occupy the same width on the spreadsheet and produce opposite instructions to anybody who opens it.

The desk's control table has 47 energy inputs with a quantity, price and status but no cause field. Their rows close when the number is entered. Methane's row stays open until the reason is attached. This is not evidence that methane costs more. It is evidence that the ledger required more of it. A form can call that accountability or administrative cost depending on which column the clerk is reading. Douglas does not let the two share a cell.

"Nothing in this file says that the gas got cheaper, safer or smaller. It says the file will stop asking it to arrive with an explanation. That is a change in the record. It is not a zero in the atmosphere."

A senior clerk on the desk's review panel, who asked to be named only as someone who had read the ledger, Wednesday

The Price Of A Question

Federal Reserve Bank of Dallas Working Paper 23-09 remains this desk's reference for the narrower proposition that a quoted risk can move before delivery. The paper does not concern methane, this ledger or this announcement. It is useful because the desk's first draft made the ordinary error: it treated a line that moved as a thing that had moved. The line moved. The gas was not measured by that line on this desk's file.

After the announcement, the desk ran a termination simulation. It removed the reason field and recalculated the rows. Cost fell from 15 review fees to zero. Quantity, price and status did not change. The ledger looked cleaner. It also stopped distinguishing no variance from no answer, which is a distinction the desk had been charging itself to maintain. This is why the Sunday file now carries two zeros: zero charge and zero explanation are not the same result.

The desk set out to price what was being terminated and expected a number. It found a cost that was not paid by the gas, the operator or the consumer in the file. It was paid by the person who had to put a reason in a box. Ending the rule removes the box. That may be an efficient use of paper. It is not a finding about what the gas does.

The real sentence is short: the President said his administration is terminating a Biden-era rule aimed at cutting methane emissions from drilling. The financial sentence is shorter: the only line item this desk can show changing is the one that says why. Douglas Merritt will not call a blank a saving. He will record it as a zero only in the column labeled questions no longer being asked, which is the first column in sunday.xlsx that has ever filled itself.

Desk note: Column F now records whether a cost was attached to the gas or to the act of explaining it. The 312 rows remain. The desk has not added a column for the atmosphere because it has no unit and because Douglas has already used all available space.